Wednesday, March 29, 2017

Electoral Reforms needed in India

India is one of the unique countries in the world. Historian Ramachandra Guha has said that India is one of the most recklessly ambitious and ambitiously reckless political experiment in modern times. That is indeed true. Consider the year 1947. India was more than 80 percent illiterate; not fully unified as there were secessionist tendencies existing in various parts of the country. Add to this the diversity both religious and linguistic. On top of this India was just coming out of a bloody partition. The wounds of partition were still so fresh. Despite these adverse circumstances, our founding fathers took an extremely bold decision. A decision that India would be a democratic country and every citizen of India irrespective of gender, education or class had the equal right to vote. The voting rights did not come in stages as it happened in most other democracies, where first men of property were given rights and after a lot of struggle women got the voting rights. In parts of Switzerland, women could not vote till as late as the 1970s. Keeping this in mind, it was an astounding decision which required not only great courage and vision but extremely great administrative skills. One of the unsung heroes of this success is a Bengali mathematician and civil servant called Sukumar Sen. This story requires another blog which I will be doing in the future. In today's post, I am going to argue that  India requires some very significant electoral reforms. I am aware that the Congress MP, Shashi Tharoor has often advocated the presidential form of democracy and has argued in its favour in his book An Era of Darkness: The British Empire in India. I have not yet read his arguments and any overlap with his ideas is purely coincidental. 

The ideas in the following paragraphs are a result of countless discussions I have had with my father who is also like me a very keen political observer.

The Parliamentary system as it exists today is fantastic in theory. It allows for regional representation in the houses both in state and the centre, for example, the Telugu Desam Party from my home state of Andhra Pradesh represents the Telugu Interests, Telangana Rashtra Samiti was formed to represent the aspirations of the people in Telangana, Jharkhand Mukti Morcha in erstwhile Bihar and current Jharkhand, the Dravidian parties represent the Tamil Interests, Shiv Sena in Maharashtra represents the Marathi Manoos spirit and so on and so forth. It also allows people of different castes to have their representatives for the Bahujan Samaj Party in Uttar Pradesh represents Dalit aspirations etc. Since it is the houses the Lok Sabha at the centre and the Vidhan Sabha at the states which decide government formation, all these voices find a place in the government making it extremely inclusive and representative. This would ensure that the government will have to work keeping in mind the collective interests of the different people of the country. To put it differently, idea is that the Parliament should represent India in microcosm and thus, such a representation would allow for inclusive governance. In addition, the parliamentarians and legislators would take care of their respective constituencies and be the voice of the people in the respective houses.

However, In the past few years, this fantastic system, in theory, is falling apart. One of the main reasons for this is the emergence of a personality cult. For instance, people in West Bengal no longer vote for their TMC legislator but vote for Mamata Banerjee to be the chief minister. Banerjee could literally place lampost and still win elections. The same is the case in almost every state Chandrababu Naidu in Andhra, Karunanidhi and late Jayalalitha in Tamil Nadu, late Bal Thackrey in Maharashtra, the Badals in Punjab, Shivraj Singh Chauhan in Madhya Pradesh, Arvind Kejriwal in Delhi etc. And since 2014, this trend seems to have crept into the central politics too. Most of the victories of the BJP are essentially victories for Narendra Modi. This trend has become particularly dangerous as we see the recent results of the Uttar Pradesh election. The electorate voted for the BJP as they wanted a Narendra Modi installed chief minister. It is not the trust in the local law-makers that is now influencing the vote of the people. But it is their choice of the Chief Minister or the Prime Minister. This kind of voting pattern completely destroys all the salient features of the Parliamentary democracy. If the local MP or the MLA is simply a lamppost and the vote is for a personality who will head the government, I will argue that we need an overhaul in the way elections are conducted. We should try to a move to a slightly presidential form of governance while keeping the parliamentary spirit. 

There is one more problem, which I believe is, even more, grave compared to the personality cult that I described. This is the policy of the parties to issue a whip. The very purpose of legislators and house is to have a disagreement, have a debate and come up with a good law. With parties issuing a "whip" all the law-makers have to toe the "party line". The individual thought process of the MP or the MLA has no meaning. It is essentially what the supreme leader of the party thinks that matters. For instance, when the MNREGA bill was introduced, I am sure there must have been many Congressmen who would have wanted to oppose it but could not as it was the "party line". The same is the case in the current regime. In fact, all the BJP lawmakers have to vote in the house in accordance with the wishes of Prime Minister Modi. This completely defeats the purpose of having a legislature. If the lawmakers do not have an independent say, what we are having is an adulterated for of Parliamentary democracy.  In fact, so bad is the system that even before the debate takes place in the house, we can sitting in our homes add up the numbers to see if the bill would be passed eventually. The talk is always about parties supporting the bill (which is a euphemism for the supreme leader supporting the bill) as opposed to the lawmakers. Quite honestly, the word lawmaker in the current system is a complete misnomer. If there "X" MPs of TMC in the house it simply means that Mamata Banerjee has "X" votes in the house. When was the last time we remember an influential speech making a difference of few votes in the house? Does it not completely defeat the whole purpose of having a parliamentary debate?

A Problem in Theory: The current system of Parliament has another problem which is in theory itself. This system doesn't really give the choice to the voters to elect their government. The electorate can merely elect their representatives, who in turn elect the government. This is completely flawed. The policies of the government, directly affect the people and probably, who the Chief Minister or the Prime Minister is, really affects the day to day life of the electorate more than who the local MLA or MP is. The recent election trends show that the electorate rather has the government of their choice rather than the representatives. We are seeing a trend where the local candidate's relevance is becoming lesser election after election.

I will now describe the proposal for central elections and I propose that an analogous election is conducted at the state and municipality levels.

  1. In every election for the centre, the voter casts two votes. One for the Prime Minister directly and one for the MP.
  2. The Prime Minister will be elected by a simple popular vote.
  3. These two votes (one for the Prime Minister and one for the MP) will be completely independent of each other.
  4. The term of the office of the Prime Minister is for four years and for the house two years.
  5. The composition of the house should not effect the Prime Minister. For instance, we could have a house where over 300 MPs are from the Congress and the Prime Minister is Narendra Modi. 
  6. The Prime Minister will have complete liberty in choosing her (or his) cabinet, and like the United States system, the cabinet ministers have to be approved by the Lok Sabha. However, there is no jurisdiction that the ministers have to belong to the house. Such a system will allow greater talent in administration. Remember that the best of administrators may be not able to win elections.
  7. The election of Rajya Sabha and its functionality remains the same.
The Prime Minister will not be all-powerful; (s)he will still have to manoeuvre through the house for her (or his) bills to be passed. But, unlike the system we have now (s)he will not be bend by coalition pressures and threats. (S)he would directly accountable to the people. 

I am of the view that the current system of elections that we have, really gives the voters very little elbow room. Let me explain what I mean by giving a concrete example. Suppose I was a voter in Mumbai or Thane in 2019. Also, suppose that I want Modi to be the Prime Minister again. But the local candidate is a goon from the BJP-ally Shiv Sena. What do I do now? Vote for the goon so that I see Modi as the Prime Minister or vote against him knowing very well, that would hurt Modi's chance, a Prime Minister whose work I liked. It is at this point that the current election system is flawed in theory. The system does not give the electorate a chance to directly vote for the government. The recent election results show that electorate wants that choice more than the choice of who would be their local representative. One of the big flaws in the current system is that an all-powerful leader like Modi, Banerjee, Patnaik can field almost anyone they wish and victory to the candidate is guaranteed because of the leader. This new proposed system is also an attempt to rectify this inherent flaw that is there in our election system.

It is important to note that this system is significantly different from the one in the United States. Unlike the United States Congress, this Parliament would truly represent India, its diversity and the aspirations of the different communities. Also, unlike the United States, a simple popular vote based method will ensure that we do not have the perils that the electoral college system and the winner take the entire state system has. 

This system will completely separate the government from the legislature. In the current system, the lines have completely blurred primarily due to the "whip" system. It will also ensure legislators are elected and not merely because they belong to a particular party but due to the work they do for their constituents and on the way they vote on different issues in the parliament, increasing their accountability to their constituents. It will thus also ensure the growth of internal democracy in the party. 

Another great advantage that comes as a by-product is that, we can cut the number of elections that we have to a much smaller number. This system will ensure that the all the elections are conducted simultaneously. Houses getting dissolved and need for fresh elections will be non-existent. This will not just save the exchequer of unnecessary expenditure but will also make sure that governments are not in constant election mode.   

I am completely aware that this debate is for only academic purposes, nevertheless, I am of the opinion that this system is more effective for the India we live in today.



2 comments:

  1. Good post Adithya.
    I totally second your opinion that people should have a say in who their PM/CM should be. I am sure no one in UP voted for BJP to see the yogi as their CM. Having the votes for PM/CM and MP/MLA independent of each other helps to take politics out of the picture when people cast their votes for their local representatives. As you said, in such a system you are free to vote for some independent candidate who has got merit as your MP and NaMo as your PM rather than getting forced to vote for some goon from SS to make sure NaMo is the PM.
    However, there are some challenges in such a system:
    1. In such a system it is very unlikely for people like Deve Gowda or Mayawati to be the PM. This is not necessarily a bad thing as only someone with a pan-India appeal would become the PM, but such a system may reduce the power of regional parties calling the shots in decision making and they will be the staunchest opponents to the implementation of such a system.
    2. There are likely to be more deadlocks in the Parliament right from the approval of cabinet members. In a situation where a BJP PM is elected to a Congress majority Lokh Sabha, it is very unlikely that the Lok Sabha would approve of any cabinet decisions made by the PM unless there are some Congress partymen in the cabinet. We need some stringent laws to be passed to prevent these countless disruptions in LS and RS. A lot of valuable time and money is being wasted for puny matters.
    It would also be better to have the state and central elections conducted at the same time.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Navjyoth,

      Thanks so much for your comment. I guess you are right about regional parties losing out. They may not lose out in state politics but, for central politics yes. Having a Pan-India appeal will be important.
      There has to be a way to prevent deadlocks, you are right! Having Loksabha election every 2 years was one way, but that may not be sufficient.

      Delete